Alright. Ended up going with the box from Lowes.
Although it was small in the depth I still wanted it. I really only wanted it to be able to carry some random items. Large objects not fitting was not an issue.
So I ordered it online and went and picked it up.
I took my box off and cleaned up what the original owner had done.
Picture below is with no box.
Here is new box from the side
Picture from the back
Hardest part was getting the massive label they had put on the front of the box. Literally took 20 mins. Overall, works well. Got my socket set, flashlights, jumper cables, etc in it.
Let me know what ya'll think. Besides the fact that it looks funny lol.