I went for cheapness factor on mine. I wanted, a slider window at the front and the sides as well as carpeted. Found on Craigslist for 250. I figure I can paint it myself or professionally and still be way cheaper than buying new. As for brands, they all look basically the exact same. All are fiberglass as well so all have the same durability I feel.
Sold:2004 XLT 4x2 Ext. Cab. 3.0 Mods: 3" spindle, AAL, shackle, 32x11.5 on 15x8s, billet grille, clear corners, flow 40 dumped, line-x, CB/PA, traction bars, lil sound system, auto up down windows
Sold:2005 XLT 4x4 Ext. Cab. 4.0 Mods: ProComp lights w/ HID swap on tabs, 32x11.5 on 15x8s, CB/PA, black out heads/corners, lil sound system, cranked t-bars, flow 40 dumped, line-x, shell, bed rug, 06+ tails, metal tail gate handle since plastic one shattered, OHC, Mustang Dome.