No, I think they should just shelf him for the season, I doubt they will win the cup anyways since the guys are tired and bruised. they should just save his career and let him really get back to 100%. If the Pens let him come back before he is fully healed and his career is over because of it, I am selling all of my Pens stuff and becoming either a Philly or Detroit fan instead (Too bad detroit is west, hard to watch them here).