Go with falkens.

I've run both BFG AT and the wildpeaks.

By far I like the wildpeaks much better.

More and more people are finally realizing it. BFG AT's are outdated, they chunk way easier, and they're ugly (which is a matter of opinion, I know)

As for the falkens sucking in mud, it's an all terrain, they all suck in deep mud.
But in mild mud they are great. Best tire I've ever used. And will continue to use it.

Especially for the price, and 50,000 mile warranty, it's honestly the best choice. Ask anyone who's switched to them from BFG's.
they're great tires.